May 23, 2012

A rocking chair made by a high school student

I got sidetracked, and did not do as promised. I have not returned to complete the slide show of the 2011 North West Technology Education Association of Missouri (TEAM) Awards contest. But I am working on it. In case you missed it, you can read my recent article showing the best entry in the woodworking category.

Some of my recent work highlighted to me the very real difficulty in perfectly matching multiple tenons into multiple mortises. And that brought me back to the high school competition. It was the rocking chair in the photo below that brought me back. All of the slats, the arms, the legs, everything in this chair is put together using mortise and tenon joinery. I can only imagine a high school student working on this chair, and matching all the joinery:

Rocking chair entry.

As if matching all the back slats perfectly were not enough, there are plenty more mortises and tenons to match on the base. The stretchers must be installed properly, to minimize racking due to the forces exerted during rocking. The rockers themselves must be secured in the proper spot, to ensure smooth rocking:

Detail of rockers.

This is one of the reasons I find the efforts of the educators in shop classes fascinating. They are showing our children the importance, and the relevance, of getting an item put together just right, of making it durable. All of this adds up to a quality item that will last a long time, rather than being placed on the sidewalk after a couple of years.

I am proud of our high schools in Missouri, for continuing to teach our youth the importance of working with our hands, to create. KUDOS, Missouri Technology Education teachers!

Al Navas

The 2011 TEAM Awards for NW Missouri

Every year I look forward to judging the high school competition called the North West Technology Education Association of Missouri (TEAM) Awards contest. Our local woodworkers Guild is invited to judge the woodworking entries, and every year eight of us are either selected, or we volunteer to judge the entries. This year the event was once again hosted by the Missouri Western State University campus in St. Joseph, MO, about 10 minutes from our house.

If you would like to read my report for the 2010 TEAM Award results, click here.

The following is the entry we felt was the best in the woodworking category, and will be going to the State competition is Sedalia, Missouri, May 5-6, 2011. We awarded this nice game table 99 points out of 100 maximum possible. The joinery was all mortise & tenon, including the mitered table top; the aprons were also joined to the legs using mortise and tenon joinery. We did not award 100 points because we felt that a little more effort would have resulted in better grain match at the mitered corners; and two of the squares were off at the corners by about 1/16-inch. That aside, the table was terrific:

Best in wood for 2011.

We spent a bit of time trying to decide whether the legs were bought, or whether they were made by the student. In the end we decided the legs were made by the student, as revealed by the variations in measurements near the bottom of the legs – it was this detail that proved a deciding factor to award a high score to this entry:

Excellent workmanship in these legs.

The table top was close to perfect. I was impressed with the perfect miters, and with the mortise & tenon joinery at the miters. And, as I mentioned above, the quality of the match of the squares in this board was near perfect:

The chess board was close to perfect!

I believe this entry will do well in competition at State level, which will be held May 5 and 6 in Sedalia, Missouri.

My impressions about the 2011 woodworking competition:

The first thing I noticed on entering the gymnasium where the competition is normally held was the significantly lower number of entries, compared to years past. There was no question in my mind that less time is being spent by High School kids working on “shop projects” or, as it called today, Technology Education. The following is the complete list of categories that make up Technology Education in Missouri:

CAM/CNC
Computer Applications
Drafting – Architectural
Drafting – Mechanical
Electricity-Electronics
Graphic Arts
Industrial Crafts
Metalwork
Open Division
Photography
Plastics
Power and Energy
Robotics
Technology Exploration
Woodworking

I am saddened by the reduced number of entries, and hope that, as a State, Missouri will find a way to reverse the trend. I am convinced that, ultimately, it is our children who will miss learning opportunities available only in the classes covered by this program. One of the main factors in decreased enrollment is a critical shortage of qualified teachers in the schools. I sincerely hope this changes during my lifetime; the State must find way to provide incentives to teachers to enter this wonderful part of our educational system.

I will continue to work on preparing a slide show of the remaining entries in the 2011 TEAM Awards, and will post it when finished.

Al Navas

The winners of the high school TEAM awards, including woodworking

I mentioned in a recent article that members of our Woodworkers Guild, including Sandy and I, would participate as judges in the 2010 North West Technology Education Association of Missouri (TEAM) Awards contest. I can report that we were impressed by the quality of the entries, and the sheer enthusiasm shown by the participants, the schools, and the Staff involved in the program in Northwest Missouri.

One of the entries in the Woodworking category scored high, but did not win (the large bed, in the gallery shown below the top two entries). The overall winner this year was not a woodworking entry, although it should have been entered as such. Instead, the First Place winner was entered in the Open Division; it was the following kayak, made by a student probably in 11th or 12th Grade (neither name nor grade level was listed on the entry sheets):

First place overall: Kayak, Open category/

The following architectural model of a house placed second overall. It was a beautiful model, with every detail of the real thing:

Second place overall: House model, architectural category.

The following is a Gallery of several of the remaining entries, to give you a flavor for the quality of the entries. It is amazing to me that high school students taking less than 10 hours of shop instruction (Industrial Technology) per week can put together the following projects:

A number of the entries will represent the Northwest Missouri District at the TEAM Annual State Contest May 6 and 7, 2010. I hope that the top entries from our District will do well.

Al Navas

Page optimized by WP Minify WordPress Plugin