September 9, 2010

The case for drawboring: Easy, and simple

Clamping large objects can test one’s contortion prowess, and can often result in less-than-perfect looking mortise & tenon joints due to unsightly gaps. I tried the drawboring technique for the first time on a new base for a (new) 60-inch long table; these usually require long clamps, and maybe a second human’s help to properly position the clamps to draw the joints tight.

I found one article (Drawboring Resurrected, Woodworking Magazine, by Christopher Schwarz, September 1, 2005)  particularly helpful as I prepared to assemble the table base using the drawboring technique. I will show my results, and leave it to the reader to read the how-to in the article by Schwarz.

I used no clamps to get the following, perfectly-tight mortise & tenon results:

Drawboring: The results

Pretty cool! I was able to do this in a fraction of the time it took me the last time I made another table base. And I was also able to eliminate most of the stress of assembling the 3-inch tenons in their mortises, by simply making the fit a little sloppy by 0.005″ (an additional five thousands of an inch), on the Leigh FMT.

Before starting on the actual table base, I did a little test as follows. I simply sliced a test joint, assembled without glue, to allow me to fully dissect it:

Drawboring: Detail 1

The photo above needs some interpretation: The tenon was inserted from the far end, toward the reader. I drilled a hole through the mortise to accept the ¼ peg; I also drilled a hole in the tenon, offset from the hole in the mortise by 1/32-inch, away from the reader.  The bend in the ¼-inch peg suggests that the place where I drilled the offset hole in the tenon was slightly off-center, relative to the hole I originally drilled through the mortise.  But this exercise confirmed that the taper I made on the tip of the peg was good enough to allow it to fully seat.

Exploring further, I removed the tenon piece from the mortise, to learn if additional details would support my conclusions above. Remember: I used no glue in this test piece.

This is what I saw:

Drawboring: More detail

The tearout  on the left side of the hole confirms (I think…) that I drilled the hole in the tenon slightly off-center. And yet the joint was pulled together perfectly tight!

I am sold on drawboring as a technique to help me get nice, tight mortise & tenon joints without using any clamps at all. And I did not have to buy any drawbore pins, as we already had some in our tool box – but we thought they were just “center punches”.

Does anyone think I could make a killing by selling the clamp extenders I bought for my Bessey clamps?

.

The Leigh FMT:

Intro to the Leigh FMT

Download Quicktime (*.mov)



In this episode I introduce Leigh Industries’ FMT, their flagship Frame Mortise & Tenon (M&T) jig. This is the latest tool in our shop.

Why the FMT? Because it excels at cutting mortises and tenons with high accuracy. With this jig we have the following options:

  1. Use the FMT to cut all integral tenons and mortises for a project. The result: Perfect-fitting M&Ts.

  2. As an alternative, cut all the mortises with the FMT, and also shape long tenons with the FMT. These tenons are then cut off on the table saw, to make loose tenons. The result: Perfect-fitting M&Ts.

  3. A secondary alternative: Use the FMT to cut all the mortises, and cut loose tenon stock on the table saw, followed by shaping on the router table. With this option the loose tenons may require some “shaving off” and tweaking to optimize the fit.

I have confirmed that the versatility, simplicity, and the ease of use of this jig was the correct decision for me. The best way I can explain this is as follows. I need to make only one layout for the mortises, and one layout for the tenons; I then select one router bit and its matching guide, and make test cuts to confirm that my layout is OK. From this point on I can make as many tenons and matching mortises as I need for a particular project.

Enjoy the video, and let me have your Comments, either here or via e-mail (please note the e-mail tab in the menu above).

Relevant links:
Leigh FMT page
Leigh video page (the FMT is near the bottom of the page – 4 videos in total)

Recognition: I thank my friend and woodworking colleague John Fry (Chisel and Bit Custom Crafted Furniture) for reviewing the draft of this post, and for his feedback.

500-40_leigh-logo.png

The Leigh FMT at Woodcraft:
LEIGH Frame Mortise & Tenon Jig at Woodcraft.com

 

 

Related Posts with Thumbnails