The Super FMT: Part 2 cont’d – more on the clamp plate

The weather is just about back to normal – we expect 4°F tonight, with (again!) winds around 15 mph. However, today was a good day to be in the shop; the furnace kept the shop at a toasty 65°F. I had a dovetail saw in hand, cutting dovetails for some drawers I must finish. And then it struck me: I had to resolve an issue I ran into with the Super FMT the last time I used it.

I like to check the joinery as I work, because it saves me headaches at dry-fit, and at glue-up time. So, checking each and every single joint is a hard-to-kick habit. After playing around with the Super FMT, moving clamps to and fro as I made mortises and then tenons, I found a misaligned joint:

mis-aligned-joint

See the light under the straight edge of the square? This means the joint is misaligned; there should be NO light under the straight edge. Take a deep breath, and start looking for the cause of the problem. My immediate thought: the table and the clamp plate were not at a perfect 90° angle to each other.

Now I must get ahead of the plan I mentioned near the bottom of an earlier thread. As I mentioned in that earlier post, I planned to cover troubleshooting in Part 5 of this series. But I now chose to ignore that part of my plan, and to give you the benefit of my findings right away. So, let us reason this out together – I will wing it:

  1. I moved the clamp plate several times, to remove and insert clamps as I switched from routing mortises, to routing tenons.
  2. The table moves only on one plane, in the X-axis (left-and-right) and in the Y-axis (front-to-back, and back-to-front). The table is, therefore, a good zero angle reference point.
  3. Both mortise and tenon pieces are machined with the same face facing me (I mark these surfaces with chalk).
  4. If the clamp plate is misaligned, and both tenon and mortise are machined with the work piece clamped flat to the plate, then the error introduced by a misaligned clamp plate (that is, with the clamp plate at an angle other than 90° ) is essentially doubled. This means that a 1° misalignment of the clamp plate relative to the table will result in a 2° misalignment of the joint. And even such a small error will be blatantly obvious.

Question: Why is the error doubled, as I mention in #4?

Answer: It is doubled because the top faces on the work pieces in the photo above are facing me while I machine them – let us assume each piece will have an error of 1°; the joint later goes together with the marks on the work pieces facing me. Thus, a 2° misalignment results; this is visible without the need for any measurement. But it is impressive when back-lit, as I have shown in the photo above — and it is a good way to for me to show you the results. Once again, the eye can tell and it can see the results of a slight joint misalignment; trust your eyes, and check joint alignment, always.

Solution: Align the clamp plate such that is at 90° to the table.

How to do this: My Wixey Digital Angle Gauge to the rescue. Simply set the clamp plate surface 90° to the table surface every time that the clamp plate is moved. First, the table is made the 0° (zero degree) reference surface:

table-zeroed

Then set the clamp plate at a perfect 90° to the table:

clamp-plate-90-deg

After routing the tenon and the mortise, the result is a perfectly-aligned joint when the clamp plate is set to 90° to the table:

well-aligned-joint

I double-checked, and my eyes were correct; I believe you can also tell that this joint is perfectly aligned, by simply looking at the photo above. Trust your eyes, but confirm it with a straight edge — always!

As I kept trying different things, I ran into the following – and when it happened, I felt serious vibration on the router itself, like a strong shudder:

ouch-table-loose

A little more troubleshooting revealed that I forgot to properly tighten the table; I had moved it to align a new work piece.

Edit to add: In addition to remembering to tighten the table, I suggest you also move the table as far left (or as far right) as possible, while still allowing sufficient space to route the mortise. This allows you to move the work piece closer to the clamps; the net result is that the mortise work piece will be better supported by the clamps, and less prone to vibration. And, before I forget, always use two clamps to support the work piece.

After resetting the table, and properly tightening it, I got the following result:

good-mortise

I will continue work on the drawers, aiming to finish them this week. Then on to the rest of that project. And, in between, a little more work with the Super FMT. Hang in there with me!

.

—— Al Navas

.

The Leigh Super FMT: getting to know it — Part 2, the clamp plate, and workholding in general

With the machine unpacked, set up, and ready to work, it was time to put it through its paces. But first I must learn a brand-new way of holding the work pieces properly. In other words, I must learn the basic workholding on the Super FMT, using the new Leigh F-style clamps. I will cover the use of outriggers in a later article.

Part 2 is all about the clamp plate, the new clamps, and the side-stop fence. The clamp plate is the front plate with many holes in it. The bar of the new F-style clamps is inserted from behind the plate, through the holes; a rare earth magnet holds the clamp in place while I position the work piece:

2-using-sfmt

After sliding the screw handle on the clamp bar, I am ready to clamp the work piece:

1-using-sfmt

It takes a little maneuvering to set up the clamps in the tight spaces that are the upper-left and the upper-right quadrants. The reason? The sides of the dust chute reduce the working space considerably. But, once the clamps are in place, they hold the work piece very well. Barring obstructions, the clamps can be rotated in the hole through a good arc, to allow the best clamping arrangement.

I used the pencil line on the work piece to set the plunged router bit depth, then moved it into position; the following photo shows an unobstructed view of a work piece as I machine a mortise:

3-using-sfmt

After machining the test mortise, I prepared the jig to clamp the tenon pieces. I started by moving the clamps to holes that will allow clamping the work piece vertically (having extra clamps on hand would be better yet). I learned I could save acrobatics by moving the clamp plate to the full open position, reaching under it, and inserting the clamp bar through an opening in the plate:

6-using-sfmt

In the next photo I push a clamp bar through the clamp plate – notice how the clamp on the right-hand side can now reach over the side-stop fence, to allow clamping the work piece:

7-using-sfmt

After returning the clamp plate to the closed position, I have the following view, from my working position – in this photo it is clear how the clamp reaches the work piece (I have already machined the tenon):

8-using-sfmt

In the following photo, taken from behind the clamp plate, you can see the clamp head below, and to the right of the dust collection hose:

In the next photo I show the tenon work piece at eye level, as I machine the tenon – the work piece is flush against the side-stop fence, it is held firmly in place, and is square to the table:

5-using-sfmt

Also from my working position, the next photo shows how the joint aligning sight – the target area is huge, and allows very precise alignment of the work piece:

4-using-sfmt

First impressions about the clamp plate, and workholding in general:

  1. The new F-style clamps work very well-they hold the workpiece securely. I was unable to make the work pieces shift, even under heavy mechanical load (my hand, shoving hard)
  2. In some areas, restrictions such as caused by the dust chute make insertion of the clamps somewhat hard. But after doing it a few times I started to get a better feel for the maneuvers.
  3. An extra set of clamps will make workholding even better, as it will virtually eliminate moving clamps during a job.
  4. I found that if I moved the clamp plate in any way, I had to check it for alignment, to ensure square joints. I am still working to find the best way to close the clamp plate repeatably after opening the clamp plate. I used a Wixey Digital Angle Gauge to do the measurements.
  5. I love workholding on my old FMT (now the Pro), which uses cam clamps. It took me a while to get used to the new F-style clamps on the Super FMT, but now I like them much better.

In Part 3 I will cover the jig’s table features, and in Part 4 the router sub-base. In Part 5 I will cover routing technique, and troubleshooting if things don’t work out right.

Right now I must go shovel some snow off the deck, and run the tractor to remove about 4 inches of snow of the driveway – we expect an additional 8 inches later today.

.

—— Al Navas

Workholding and consistency with the Leigh FMT frame mortise & tenon jig

Workholding and consistency/repeatability, in addition to the superb accuracy and precision of the Leigh FMT jig! One question from a reader prompts me to write this.

After reading one earlier post on this blog, Charles in Houston, TX, asked if I had much trouble aligning the twin mortises with the tenons properly, to ensure a)_square fit, and b)_easy and tight assembly.

I thought it would be best to show how I do it, and what I recommend, using photos. And if you are reading this and spot a problem with my definitions, concepts, or procedure, please let me know in the Comments section of this post (linked just below the title for this post), or via e-mail to sandal_woods@bbwi.net.

First, some definitions and one image:

From Class Vocabulary at Tooling University, LLC:

accuracy: The difference between a measurement reading and the true value of that measurement.

repeatability: The ability to obtain consistent results when measuring the same part with the same measuring instrument.

precision: The degree to which an instrument will repeat the same measurement over a period of time.

And from Understanding Precision and Accuracy,CHE 353M, Fall 2002 at the Wilson Research Group, the University of Texas at Austin:

 

accuracy-precision

The FMT is inherently a very accurate and precise instrument – it was made to be so (bottom-right on the bull’s eye image above). This means it can make a mortise and tenon joint that fits very well; and  better yet, to do so even if multiple mortises and multiple tenons are present on stretchers like the ones below:

 

stretcher-double-tenons-2

And the FMT can do all of this accurately, repeatably, and precisely; using calipers I can verify the thickness of the mortise and the tenons, and their length and width. Of course, I must be able to set up the machine properly to do so. But I must do the layout accurately, to get the results I want.

I want these stretchers to be centered on the legs, such that the eye cannot tell misalignment or misplacement. This is where I must also be accurate with the layout and measurements, and with positioning of the legs and the stretchers on the jig. Once I do this, I put my work on the bottom-right of the image above, close to the bull’s eye. I am helping the FMT work for me, to give me the results I need.

Now, to answer the question Charles posed: Do I have much trouble aligning the mortises and/or the tenons properly, to ensure square fit and assembly, and position on the legs? My answer is no, I have no trouble at all doing so. I take some precautions to lay out the joints; and more precautions and care to properly position not only the work pieces on the jig, but also to move and to position the jig’s sliding table to the dimensions I need. To accomplish all of this repeatably, I use the workholding capability of the jig, as I explain below.

Working with scrap pieces to set up the joinery on the FMT, I found the legs to be very heavy. In fact, I felt I needed to ensure no movement during the machining of the mortises on the legs, as the bulk of the leg would be cantilevered on one side. Enter workholding, using clamps:

 

workholding-full-front-view

workholding-full-left-view

Using this arrangement, I was satisfied the heavy legs would not move as I plunged the 3/8-inch router bit into the wood.

Now, some details.

First, positioning and holding the work piece is critical. This is accomplished on the FMT with clamps on the body of the jig, and on the outrigger assemblies. The jig body accepts cam-action speed clamps — the four clamps holding the leg in the photo below; on the outriggers I use any other type of clamp that won’t slip under pressure or light bumping:

 

workholding-clamps

The FMT ships with two Cam-Action clamps. I bought two additional ones:

 

workholding-cam-actionclamps

In the photo above, the vertical fence in the center is used to register one side of the stretchers when the tenons are machined. I leave it in place for the duration of all machining operations. Once set, it is extremely difficult to move; it will move if bumped hard with a heavy work piece. But I recommend double-checking its position once in a while.

It is possible to use just about any type of clamp on the outriggers. However, I recommend staying away from spring clamps, as their holding ability with large pieces, such as the heavy legs I machined in this example, is marginal at best. In the next photo, taken from behind the outrigger, I show a Bessey bar clamp holding the leg, as extra insurance from (primarily) vertical movement due to the mass of the leg:

 

workholding-left-outrigger-clamp

And on the right outrigger board, a FatMax Xtreme speed clamp:

 

workholding-rightt-outrigger-clamp

This clamping arrangement on the right outrigger is the key to accurate positioning, and re-positioning of the legs, for reproducible machining of the mortises. The end of the leg is registered against the edge of the board held tightly in place by the clamp. Barring any unforeseen problem, the board stays in place until all leg mortises are machined.

In summary:

  • The FMT is a wonderful jig that allows machining of mortises and tenons very quickly and accurately.
  • As users, we can influence the results we get with it; care in positioning a work piece reduces the chances of moving a fence or reference point.
  • As good as the FMT is, I recommend taking precautions and measures to ensure reproducible positioning and re-positioning of work pieces machined on this jig.
  • I suggest care in layout and measurements.
  • Always use scrap pieces to set up the machine properly, not your precious project boards.
  • Check to ensure the router bit has not shifted position – it is possible that, on some routers, the bit will go deeper in the collet, resulting in shallow mortises and short tenons.
  • Make sure the plunge depth on the router has not changed.
  • And finally, conduct periodic checks of the jig setup, whether stops on the outriggers, or the position and squareness of the vertical fence used to machine the tenons, or the table movement X- and Y-axis stops.

My thanks to Charles in Houston, TX, for your question. I hope your question and my answers and suggestions will also help other readers!

.